Create Amazing Color

Film Noir

Buy Now

Categories

Feb 07, 2012

Softboxes vs. Umbrellas

Which lights produce which effects

Softboxes produce a different effect than the umbrellas, here we show you the difference and how you can use it to your advantage.

The bigger the softbox the softer your shadows. Different types can produce different effects, and it’s not only the size that can change the final image but also the shape and distance from the camera. Timeline

  • 0:20 Our new studio
  • 1:00- Lighting effects of umbrellas and how they effect your image
  • 2:30- Example of light from umbrella
  • 2:45- Softbox lighting
  • 3:20- Anatomy of a softbox
  • 4:15- OCTOBOX
  • 5:44- Moving the light source farther away
  • 6:15- Why I prefer softboxes
  • 6:30- Adam Elmakias version
  • 6:48-Using a grid

Which do you prefer and why? Let us know!

Click on image to see it larger

27 Comments


user image You
(will not be published)

Guests are limited to images that are no larger than 1MB, with a maximum size of 2000x2000 pixels. Only jpeg, jpg, png file types.

  • user image
    Sebastian Ortiz

    Great episode, altho’ you should’ve showed an example of using the “Adam Elmakias Strip Box” … to see what it looked like for those that don’t have one. …. HAHAHAAA!!!.

  • user image
    Greg Smith

    This is about the Contest that is ending today!
    Do we really want to see Aaron edit the same kind of running through fields, with a large sky shot in the background photo that is repeated in a lot of his work? We want some change! Introduce some really gory horror imagery, add some disturbing element to a new theme of photography. If you want something different in the next Phlearn Pro please follow this link and like my photo
    http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=346640238689706&set=o.222807667729660&type=3&theater 
    Thank you, Have a good day

  • user image
    Eugenio Ojeda

    I use both and works great if you put them in a right way, and sometimes only the flash without anything works great for highlights (:

  • user image
    Anonymous

    Thanks Aaron for the great video and look forward to seeing more stunning videos from the Phlearn Studio.  My question is, is there a big difference in using Paul C. Buff’s softboxes vs the Elinchrom’s softboxes?

      • user image
        Anonymous

        Thanks man.  My budget for new lighting gear is a little tight and I wanted to get the most bang for my bucks.  I would love, love to have elinchrom gear, but if Mr. Buff’s gear can do the same thing, well I am going for the Buff gear.  Thanks for sharing.

    • user image
      Ryan Prentiss

      Only difference is the durability. I own items from both companies, but only Elinchrom items would I dare to build and take apart continuously. The PCB items I build once, and lay them in the corner.

  • user image
    Nick Bedford

    There’s also one thing to note about the distance of your light. If your light is further away, by the time it reaches the subject, the attenuation (1/r² for a point source) is approaching a more linear falloff which means the background will be brighter in relation to the subject.

    Having a light right next to the subject will afford a darker background because the light is falling off quicker at closer distances.

  • user image
    Epiphany_media

    Umbrellas and octoboxes make better catchlights so I never use softbox in front of the subject.

  • user image
    Bryan Dockett

    I like softboxes also but I since I use the smaller speed lights like the sb600 I also the soft lighter II by photek. They are basically a umbrella-softbox hybrid.  For those who don’t know about them check them out here:
    http://www.diyphotography.net/photek-softligher-ii-a-product-review and http://strobist.blogspot.com/2010/06/softlighter-too.html and here http://www.photekusa.com/Softlighter.html  
    They come in 3 sizes and also work also with small strobes likes alien bee units. Cons: No grids, you also lose the feathering of a softbox around the edgeAnother and maybe better choice would be westcott apollo softboxes

    • user image
      mike

      i saw a behind the scenes vid for the pic on the left.  he used a large softbox. idk what he used for the right, I’m guessing a beauty dish. 

  • user image
    Christopher Odd

    Great video Aaron!

    In regards to preference over the other, I really feel taht you need to have images side by side to a see a major difference…that being said, I prefer the softbox for a different reason than just the light it casts.

    The main reason I choose a softbox is for the catch light in the eye.  Over the past 6 months or so, I’m always looking at catch lights in photos and I love the way a softbox creates the square in the eye.  Maybe, as Aaron alluded to, it’s because it resembles window lighting to some extent.

    Thanks for the vids man! Love the Phlearn team.  And this community…baller. ;)

  • user image
    Hasan Jensen

    Nice video. I’d like to learn more about using softboxes/umbrellas for sure and you’ve put it quite simply. 
    I would however have liked to have seen more side-by-side comparisons of the images that you took to demonstrate the difference visually.